Editorial by Terry Gotham
Unless you’ve been under a really big, non-dusty rock, you’ve heard about the sabotage/accident/Tusken Raider attack at the White Ocean camp during Burning Man 2016. As my editor has reported, dozens of news outlets have reported on the story, big and small, from left wing to the Drudge Report. Lots of people have offered stories and explanations for what happened, but I think a lot of them miss the mark. I’d like to offer an explanation that draws on the commodification of Burning Man, the shooting of Gabby Giffords, and one of my favorite TV shows, Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex. We may never know who really did it and why, so let’s stop with the poorly supported, largely assumed narrative that’s been constructed by journalists since the man burned last weekend.
If you’re not familiar with Ghost In The Shell, I highly recommend it. The movie, but even more so the 2 season show, explored the cybernetic & internet-everywhere world we’re hurtling towards as a species. In NeoTokyo, a “stand alone complex” occurs, a series of corporate hacks expose government corruption, blamed on a single actor sparking a movement and revolution in cyberspace. In reality, there’s no actual team of people with an agenda, things are happening totally independently of each other. However, because the internet is watching and being drawn along, never truly seeing the whole picture, the populace believes “something” is happening, when things aren’t. This is the nature of a stand alone complex. When you don’t have all the evidence, your mind draws whatever line through discrete events that makes sense.
The two competing stories so far have been class warfare vs. personal vendetta. On the class warfare side, White Ocean is a plug and play hotel for the elite. Bucket listers show up, hang out, get fucked up, Burn, party until the sunrises, then head home, have earned a tremendous amount of ire over the last couple of years. White Ocean has attempted to defray the concerns that they cater to the elites by discussing the size of their speaker system and the fact that they feed Burners. Many have spent time debating who actually gets fed at White Ocean, and of course, there are a miasma of opinions surrounding the deployment of EDM/commercial DJs to the playa, so I won’t belabor their points. While the case is slowly building that they can provide benefit to the greater playa, the idea of Burning Man VIP is a sticky accusation that many elite camps have done a poor job defending against. Plenty of people have come to the defense of White Ocean because they camp in similar levels of comfort, but I wanted to point out that there are plenty of uber wealthy/influential people who don’t earn that kind of scorn. Susans Sarandon shows up, works, and then has a ceremony using the Temple honorably and in a way that invited participation. Some of David Bowie’s ashes were burned at the Temple this year as well. I assume everyone associated with that was decently well off, and somehow, they managed to be respectful to the wider playa community and be wealthy at the same time.
The other side is that White Ocean stiffed a bunch of workers, so the workers retaliated. Not because of the revolution, but because “Fuck you I want my check.” This explanation tends to hold water once the facts of the sabotage are reviewed. It’s really difficult to do the level of damage that occurred at a camp without being seen, and White Ocean had actual guards posted in their camp. The idea that some socialist Solid Snake infiltrated the camp, wasn’t seen by anyone, and made off after doing so, is a reach even for the guys I hear on playa detailing the underground cities and hyperloop transports the government has created in case of nuclear war. If you saw a cook or a campmate wandering around you camp, you wouldn’t think anything of it. I assume White Ocean didn’t exactly broadcast that they stiffed these people, so the camp wasn’t on high alert. If a couple of peeps were really burnt about getting stiffed, it would’ve been trivially easy to do what happened to White Ocean, without being flagged as an intruder. But, here’s the thing, people don’t believe that, because they’ve built this pre-existing narrative about class warfare over the attacks, and see a Stand Alone Complex, where there is none.
I want to emphasize that doing this is not only human nature, but also how we evolved. The ability to recognize patterns with incomplete data kept us alive in the jungle, and helped teach us how to farm. Some of the highest paying jobs in Silicon Valley are for people who can spot patterns in data that no one else can. So it’s no surprise that everyone & their mom has tried to figure out why sabotage and why White Ocean. But, as Freud says, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. We increasingly live in a world where people will have access to massive amounts of data, that still provide an incomplete picture. This causes us to have faith in the model/trend line we built, but that doesn’t mean it’s anymore correct than it was when we saw “predator eyes” on a leaf instead of a moth and ran like scared apes 125,000 years ago.
Lots of people are talking about class warfare as if there’s some directed attempt to stoke socioeconomic resentment by certain groups on the playa, and when I read this stuff, I keep thinking back to how quickly we lost the plot after Gabby Giffords (US Congresswoman from AZ) was shot in 2011. The shooter, diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia after years of drug abuse, was convicted of the mass shooting, but also totally dehumanized as a puppet of the NRA, or a martyr for states rights. First came the ham-handed attempts to blame Fox News & Sarah Palin, ensuring that a nuanced discussion about how incendiary rhetoric affects the public consciousness would never happen. Then, the rush to demonization of the shooter as a super-villain, cold and calculating, fighting as a standard bearer for all that the NRA/GOP/your arch nemesis stood for. This guaranteed the discourse devolved into team sport, talk radio, and Facebook sparring. Someone shot a sitting Congressperson and not a single policy change came out of it. That’s startling to me, even to this day.
I’m seeing this happen right now in the comment threads, think pieces and tweet storms about White Ocean. Not only are large numbers of people hailing this person as some kind of working class hero, but the real problems of turnkey camps are taking a back seat to faux outrage and slap fights. Let’s be real, unless you were camping at White Ocean, this problem does not affect you. Period. It’s not a portend of violence to come, and it’s not going to filter into open “rebellion” on playa, so we all need to dial this pearl clutching back. While we’re being real, I’m not going to spend a lot of time being terrified that a camp for people who live in the Capitol of The Hunger Games was fucked with. Even in the worst case scenario, how long would it take White Ocean to get resupplied, via air if necessary? An hour? Two? Five? While the average burner would be fucked by this event, I’m still not clear on how this could have been anything but a minor annoyance. Not because you’re turn-key, like the White Ocean FB post said they were told by BMOrg, but because you’re FABULOUSLY WEALTHY. If how much you spend at Burning Man doesn’t even appear as a line on your yearly budget, I have no doubt contingencies existed to ensure no harm came to anyone at the camp. And if they didn’t, after this attack, I assume all turn key camps will simply bake that contingency plan cost into the price of your FuturePod or whatever the package will be called next year.
White Ocean isn’t closing up shop, no other turn key camps have announced they won’t be returning to the playa because of it, so, that aspect of the burn won’t change. And, considering their blotches of red on the MOOP Map from 2015, 9 days out, I hope they did better this year, as it seems we all have progress to make. As for the likely saboteurs, I’m a fiesty fucker, but even I’m not trying to pick a fight with rich Saudis or Russians. I truly hope law enforcement finds the culprit before they do.
At the end of the day, many are using this event to push a narrative that they most likely held before the event happened. I heard a lot of people talk about how horrifying this attack was, not realizing just how much more they spend on their average Burn than many Burners out there. The same thing happens when the poor start cheering for destruction and rebellion, not realizing that they’re actively calling for terrorism against people who, you know, work there. I found it terrifying that people were advocating for harm/further attacks/sabotage against these camps, totally glossing over a lot of people at these camps are either non-rich guests, paid staff, or simply tourists. The idea that they’d be forced to suffer simply to make a point about participation or “the priniciples” is some Daesh level bullshit. Both sides have put their insecurities on display, and are using the same event to advance their own agenda. Hopefully something like this doesn’t happen next year, but if it does, let’s try and keep a clear head about it next time.
This is the anniversary of the Giffords shooting. Looks like things have only gotten worse.
White Ocean never filed a police report:
“Without an official report, which the camp leads never made, Allen could not investigate the criminal ransacking.”
The entire thing didn’t happen, period.
Time to get back to work on my post-apocalypse bunker under a really big, non-dusty rock. Looks like I should just skip the internet connection.
Can I just say for no particular reason other than sheer loathing that… In 2017 I hope Bear Kittay gets bitten in the face by a disease laden shit house rat.
Then we can have him replaced by this guy, who would represent the tru burner spirit, much to the dismay of the Borg: https://vid.me/YJEN
Hey Terry Gotham, I just wanted to give a shout out for your very observant, sober and insightful assessment of what’s *really* wrong with the whole sordid White Ocean affair.
Well done and very much appreciated.
Wow, seriously, thank you so much. I feel like sometimes I’m just shouting into the void, and comments like this are supremely appreciated.
Good link. Some tasty tidbits:
“White Ocean had trailers and it had yurts, pretty much the same as the rest of Black Rock… White Ocean was not some hermetically sealed bubble, some cocoon that protected its denizens from the harsh realities of Black Rock City.”
“Any burner could easily find us and walk right on in, just like any other camp. Well, it’s nicer than most camps. But that’s not the point.”
“Is everyone at White Ocean rich? Definitely not. For one thing, I’m certainly not. At least not at the moment. I’ve been rich. I should be rich. I’ll be rich again soon. It costs a lot to stay at White Ocean. So a lot of us were guests of friends who could afford it.”
“But let’s be honest. All camps are not created equal. White Ocean is luxurious by Burning Man standards. I never had to build, never had to cook, and I never had assigned clean-up duties, although some guests did.”
“But I didn’t have to worry about the water level in my tank or the sewage in my whatever-it-is. These things were handled for me, by people who knew what they were doing and were paid to be there.”
“Which brings us to the Ten Principles of Burning Man. From my experience, White Ocean doesn’t seem to be in conflict with nine of them.”
“I think it really comes down to the principle of Radical Self-Reliance. To be honest, we’re not perfect. The camp was assembled and disassembled by others. Our meals were cooked for us. And while we helped out to an extent, someone else did the dishes. But let’s not forget one thing: All of these “others” were still White Ocean Burners. They too came and felt the burn. And by the way, I didn’t help create any of the art on the Playa either. But I certainly did enjoy it.”
“Maybe it wasn’t radical. But it was certainly self-reliance. If the test requires 100% adherence to all ten principles, then perhaps we failed. But so would thousands of burners in plenty of camps. Frankly, I’d give us a 95/100. And that’s usually good enough.”
“But you know what? The day that they decided to let planes land on the playa, all of this became inevitable. First off, no one can travel in and out with all of their own food and gear on a plane. It just doesn’t work that way. Second, it brings to Burning Man some folks, like myself, who simply wouldn’t be coming otherwise.”
Welcome to Burnt Man. This is not my home. I will see you elsewhere.
Did anyone monitor the BRC airport like I suggested? I suppose not.
This is my response to that posting:
This group is just a symptom of a greater illness afflicting the event which is the Burning Man Organization. They shown their presumed values to be nothing but a farce and that they, like the crowd they’re trying to cultivate, are more interested in money, fame, and influence than anything else. I think the heyday of the BM event is over and will not come back. Gone are the free spirits, rebels, and non-conformists that were the real wealth of the event. What remains to be seen is how long the reputation the event gained during its early days can be exploited and twisted to make others believe it’s still that event.
Our comments are pitiful. Check out the comments on that blog. There were 2 or 3 when I first saw it. Now well over 100. Wonder if he bothered to read them all. I am betting not.
Also note that this is the only post in his blog. Might be a hack, given how over-the-top the idiocy is. It’s frightening to think it is real.
Still haven’t seen/read any proof that the vandalism happened.
Also, any celebrity who doesn’t use their time on the playa to promote themselves, their brand image, as edgy (which is a form of commodification) then I’ll be a fan. Sarandon doesn’t qualify – just another playa celeb selfie queen.
I like the story told, back in the good ‘ole days, when Sting showed up for one camp. In less than 10 minutes he had a carpenter’s belt on and a hammer, and got to work like everyone else. That’s a celebrity to me: any comitted burner.
Thank God for room service, house keeping, and the engineering department at hotel white ocean.. I am sure the residents were devastated that they had to come back to the house of horrors after a long mind altering night on the playa. Must have been hell to have to sit at the bar or on one of the cushions with carpet under your feet while engineering had to get your front door open, and housekeeping had time to turn down your bed and put a mint on your pillow….. God life Sucks!
Was it bullshit that this happened? Yes. Would I have ever thought it would have? No hell, I was pissed when I started hearing lock up your bikes. I remember when that wasn’t a worry.
Is this gonna stop W.O. from returning probably not. Will they hire more “security” probably. We know they won’t have guard dogs – no dogs on the playa- rule.
I personally want to thank white ocean for the entertainment they provide. I couldn’t ask for more. Do I want to be fed by white ocean? No, and probably 99.9% of the rest of the playa doesn’t want their food either. Do I want to sit in the hospitality suite while at BM?. Fuck no, what’s the point of coming to the Playa and sitting in a tent. Get out and enjoy what BM has to offer – you damn sure can’t get it anywhere else. No matter how nice of a hospitality suite you are in…
Was it probably a pissed off current worker bee or ex worker bee who got shafted either verbally or monetarily? My guess is yes…. like sand in an hour glass, so are the days of our life.
I am very much looking forward to 2017. I won’t be a resident at white ocean as I don’t know any of the big wigs, and I don’t roll that way. Although if any of the head honchos would like to invite me in for a beer, ( hint, hint ) I would love come by and shoot the shit with you, shake your hand and tell you thanks for the entertainment!
“…and tell you thanks for the entertainment!”
And therein lies the problem.
Will the Borg hypocritically bitch at everyone else about the Tin Principles if they aren’t well-connected and will folks like Mark McCormack not even bat an eye? Yes.
I find the mot upsetting thing by far about plug and play etc. to be the mistreatment of the workers who do everything to build, run and break down the hotel, er, camp. Treating employees as contractors so they don’t get benefits, working people illegal amounts of hours, not paying them properly- or not at all- and on and on. Of course, the is the not some aberration: the BORG does this with it’s own volunteers, (under)paid positions without benefits, etc. I care that these people violate most of the 10 Principles. However, if I stop going to the Playa, it ill be because I don’t want to support with my money the ill treatment of fellow human beings. Posting guards to keep the riffraff out is one thing. Actively exploiting people is IMO quite another.
Rob, you are wrong! Just ask anyone who flew in to be there:
“These things were handled for me, by people who knew what they were doing and were paid to be there. And as far as I know, when they had completed their tasks they were free to experience the burn, which is great. Anyone I spoke to who was there to work, said they were loving the experience and would do it again. Some had been for years. Were it not for these people, many of us would probably never have made it to Burning Man.”
It’s Burnt Man. If you can’t afford to do it, then look for a job cleaning out the RV tanks. As Larry said, Equality is not one of the Tin Principles.
I just want to know what landfill David Bowie is in . Who did the disposal of the clean up from the Temple Burn? I would like to start a fund raiser for a monument in front of the landfill he is now scattered.
Probably within the Labyrinth somewhere.
The whole thing has been an interesting example of the absolute SHITE “journalism” going on with mainstream media. The Reno Gazette published a legitimate article with actual reporting and some quotes from the White Ocean Facebook page and some commenters. Literally every other story published afterwards borrowed entirely from the Gazette and simply added the more sensational comments from Facebook. Pathetic.
I really like your Stand Alone Complex theory. I think we both know someone who could benefit from its adoption, ha.